| Song | Artist | |
| Behold Messiah | River Valley Worship | |
| Joy! | Elevation Rhythm | |
| Silent Night | Sarah Kroger | |
| All I Bring | Anthem Worship | |
| Hark | Thrive Worship | |
| What Christmas Really Is | Thrive Worship | |
| O Come O Come Emmanuel | Rachael Mann | |
| Angels (Glory to God) | Phil Wickham | |
| Glory Hallelujah | Selah (feat. Mike Weaver) | |
| Hark the Herald Angles Sing | We Are Messengers | |
| Silent Night, Holy Night | Phil Wickham | |
| Our Christ Is Here | Jordan St. Cyr | |
| It Came Upon a Midnight Clear | Hannah Kerr & Austin French | |
| Sleigh Ride | Francesca Battistelli | |
| Silent Night (Rewrapped) | For King and Country | |
| O Come All Ye Faithful | Tori Harper (feat. Joey Stamper) | |
| Tonight | Point of Grace | |
| Greatest Gift | Anthem Lights | |
| God With All of Us | JJ Heller | |
| Come Adore Him | Riley Clemmons |
